Not Regretting Motherhood (but Resenting It a Little)

Last night I found myself crying in the bathroom. I was tired and overwhelmed and I felt like I just couldn’t do anything right. That, and my five-year-old had just spilled his cup of water onto my laptop (the one I didn’t recently drop and break), so I was prematurely mourning the loss of four little lifetimes’ worth of photos.

(Thank goodness, somehow Old Faithful withstood the spill.)

As I cried, I felt a miserable sort of irony at the scene. Here I was, fresh off a string of admiring “I don’t know how you do it” comments from friends and acquaintances, and the truth was that I’m not actually all that satisfied with how I do it.

“It” being raising four, almost five small kids. Doing the work necessary for their care and for the maintenance of a household and a marriage, all while putting on a smiling face for the world.

I don’t think I’m a wreck; I don’t think I’m a bad mom. I know that my kids are well cared for, that they feel loved, and that on many days, I truly am doing my best. (So please don’t feel like you need to affirm me here.)

But I also know my own heart. I know that I’m selfish and resentful and intolerant, and in some ways I’ve wasted these precious first years of marriage and motherhood by wishing them to be something other than they are.

I’ve resisted the limitations that these beautiful kids have put on me. I’ve railed against my constraints. I’ve reveled in the kisses and hugs and wide-eyed stories, but wished that even they could be limited to set, predictable hours of the day.

I’ve focused on what I don’t have: physical autonomy and a wide-open mental space for ideas and accomplishments and order. Freedom.

(Just now I jumped out of my skin at two boys who were playing too loudly while I was trying to finish this post. Like, “How dare you be kids while I’m trying to think?”)


A few nights ago I had a dream about my old workplace. I was visiting it for some reason, wanting to help out my old colleagues, I think. But underneath the official excuse (whatever it was), I know I was there because I wanted a taste of my old life.

I wanted to be in on interesting things. I wanted to push my mind, not just my physical stamina. I wanted to be around people who make things happen. I wanted to see my accomplishments listed out, easily numbered. I wanted to feel important.

Not that I don’t think I’m doing important things now. I know I am; I feel the awful, awesome weight of this responsibility down to my core. But in the day to day living of it, motherhood’s importance is the kind you can take for granted.

Shuttling groceries in and out of the house doesn’t feel important. Wiping crumbs from under the table doesn’t feel important. Dressing wiggly, screechy little bodies doesn’t feel important. (And forcing them to sit on the potty is downright miserable.)

And so the time passes. You focus on what needs to get done in the here and now, and you can lose sight of why you do it. Children grow quickly, but they grow slowly too.

If we could get glimpses into our futures, of the men and women our children would become, perhaps we would find the drudgery more noble. Perhaps it would be easier to set aside the daydreams of freedom and the memories of what our lives were like before they were tied up (or down) by the next generation. Perhaps it would be more tempting to see these years as precious.

I will admit that I’m not there right now.

Right now, I’m so wistful for space and freedom that I push away kids who want closeness. Right now, I’m made anxious and agitated by the mess, yet I’m unable to keep up the pace necessary to deal with it. Right now, I’m distracted by my own disorganization. Right now, I’m desperate for an active life of the mind, yet I can’t focus well enough to pursue it.

This gig is relentless, and I don’t take too kindly to Relentless.

While I absolutely do not regret giving my entire thirties over to the dishes and the diapers and the dirty laundry that come with having children and caring for them 24/7, I do resent it a little. I miss what else might have been done in these years. (Which is ironic, considering that I spent my entire twenties resenting the things I was doing instead of having children.)

For the first time, I think I understand the desire to pursue career alongside motherhood, or even instead of it. I know that those paths were not for me, but I see their attraction.


Now back to that bathroom, I guess. Last night I cried because my pictures might be gone. And because the kids were too much for me. And because I wasn’t enough for them.

I cried because I never get around to backing up the photos, or even printing them out to display in our home. I cried because I can’t be trusted not to break my computers. I cried because I haven’t had a clear kitchen sink in a week. I cried because my backyard gardens look like jungles and my driveway is growing over with weeds and I never get around to them, either. I cried because I’m behind on getting my kids to do their summer homework and I haven’t taken them to the library in years. (Literally: years.)

I cried because I’ve been feeling uncharacteristically jealous of other moms lately – the ones who print pictures and do yardwork and go to the library. The ones who travel and take their kids to shows. The ones who can count professional accomplishments alongside parental ones.

And then I cried because here I am, crying about overgrown flower beds and summer homework when we might be going to (nuclear) war with North Korea. And an entire generation of Syrian children have been scarred, forever damaged by a war thrust upon them by grown-ups who care more about power than people. And plenty of kids here in our own country go without food and love and stable places to live, let alone trips to the library.


I’m not trying to say that I regret my choices. I love my kids more than I could possibly express. I love my husband and I’m glad to be pursuing this worthwhile work alongside him. I love my life.

But somehow that doesn’t stop me from resenting it a little too. The world is big and our lives are short and there’s only so much we can fit into our day-to-day. I think it’s okay to mourn the stuff we can’t fit, as long as we don’t lose sight of all that we can.

And I know that I need to do a better job of that.

These Walls - Not Regretting Motherhood but Resenting It a Little

15 thoughts on “Not Regretting Motherhood (but Resenting It a Little)

  1. I nodded in agreement throughout this entire post. I’m in the same boat…wouldn’t change my life for anything but I still desire some change. I’m anxious and so desperately want to get my list of things done. I’ve had “clean out iPhone pics” and “new pics in house frames” on my list for a year and the task has just been too overwhelming to even tackle and it drives me bananas. Anywho, thanks for your writing and your honesty. We do hard things and it will all be worth it.

  2. Oh, Julie. I could so easily put myself in your place!! So many times I’ve found myself crying, (maybe in the bathroom, maybe on the floor of my closet). This whole mothering gig is HARD! It takes so much sacrifice and it can be so overwhelming sometimes. But I also get what you said about comparing your troubles to the grander scheme of things in the world at large. Doing that makes what we’re going through a bit inconsequential, but don’t go there. Stay the course, have your cry, know that what you’re feeling is real and honest and worth something. Then pray for the world and large and know that, for today at least, all you can do is make your little corner of the world a better place. (Spoken by a mom whose kids used to all be little but are now blessedly bigger…and busier.)

  3. I agree with every word. I’m sorry things seem so hard right now. My kids are bigger now, and things are hard in different ways, but there is slightly more opportunity to nurture the life of the mind. Slightly. 😉

  4. I’m no longer in your trenches. My “boys” are 26 and 29. It was all worth it, but I cannot say I didn’t feel like you. I once called a friend because I could not stand another minute of listening to my son’s voice. I chose not to homeschool because either I or my younger son would probably have had to die if I did. Thanks for the honesty. And from someone who has come out the other side, it is indeed all worth it. That I have young men who actually LIKE to spend time with me is nothing short of a miracle. .So hang in there. I think you are normal.

  5. Right there with you. Currently I’m 26 weeks pregnant with number 3 and actually feeling the best I’ve felt in…26 weeks, ready to tackle any project (as long as I get my afternoon nap!) but prone to these bouts of panic because I know soon I’ll be getting slower and sleepier and creakier. Mothering littles is such a tough, overwhelming season!

  6. As you know I’ve never been a mom, so I don’t know the particular struggle from personal experience. I do know that what you and other moms of multiple littles are doing is historically unusual. You don’t have relatives around to share the burden, or (probably) neighbors who can watch the kids for five minutes. You’re peculiarly isolated as the only adult for hours on end. So hell yes it’s overwhelming! It totally makes sense to feel burdened, exhausted, resentful at times. And the internet culture of super moms can’t help 😦

  7. Pingback: Weekend Links 8.19.17 | Kathryn Anne Casey

  8. Ugh. Don’t sweat the library; it’s just a cesspool of germs anyway. Our oldest is almost 5, and it’s only been within the past year that we can go to the library and not have colds within two days of visiting.

    • Yeah, that’s pretty much why we haven’t been in years. The last time we went, all anybody wanted to do was play in the play area (why do they have play areas in libraries these days?) and then everybody came down with a super-bad bug. Which turned me off of the library for some time… and then I pretty much forgot it was an option. 😉

  9. I nodded along the whole time I was reading this, Julie. The disorganization and the inability to do anything about it is really taxing me right now. Like, I can SEE how our house and lives should be run and how some simple changes would be lifesavers but I am incapable of having the time to actually make those changes. It is maddening. I’m sorry you are struggling, too.

  10. I feel like i could have written this. It’s kind of uncomfortable but eye opening to see my thoughts written down. I’m thankful but sort of not that it seems relatively normal.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.