A Vote of No Confidence in the Republican Party

A week ago, I was feeling a punchy sort of delight in the wackiness of that particular moment in politics. I was noticing a strange phenomenon in my media consumption (social and otherwise): cohesion. A sense of togetherness, a shared purpose. Half the nation seemed to be biting its collective fingernails over a common bogeyman: Donald Trump.

I saw liberals pleading for their fellows to switch party affiliation so they could help select a more palatable Republican nominee. I saw conservatives pledging support for a third-party candidate or even (gasp!) the dreaded Hillary Clinton should Trump receive the Republican nomination. I read solid cases against him and detailed strategies for ensuring he lost the nomination. I saw #NeverTrump, #AnyoneButTrump, #StopTrump, and #MakeDonaldDrumpfAgain. I read virtually identical anti-Trump Facebook posts from my most liberal and my most conservative friends.

It seemed ironic to me that the thing to bring so many of us together across party and ideological lines was our shared horror at the thought of being governed by The Donald. Could Trump, in some backwards way, prove to be our nation’s great unifier after all? My poli-sci major brain was half-way giddy at the prospect.

Today, though, those feelings have evaporated. All I feel is dread.

I mourn the loss of Marco Rubio, my favorite of this year’s candidates. But more than that, I mourn the loss of the hope that somehow this race would turn around. That somehow the two-thirds of Republicans who disapprove of Trump would get it together well enough to settle on a strong, honorable candidate for the presidency. And that such a candidate would be able to work towards healing the Republican Party (and later, the country).

Today, those hopes seem lost.

More than that. Today, I think I’ve finally given up hope in the Republican Party. And that is so hard for me to admit.

I grew up in the Party, wearing my Republican granddad’s campaign shirts at parades and fundraisers, urging my elementary school classmates to support George H.W. Bush’s campaign and my college classmates to support his son’s. I defended Reagan and Bush and Dole and Bush and McCain and Romney.

But I think I’m done now.

I’m reminding myself that politics is, at its core, nothing more than the method by which differently-minded people work out how to govern together. And that political parties are nothing more than tools to make that process function more efficiently.

As groups of (ever-changing) people, Parties’ principles, the ideas that bond them together, shift over time:

There is nothing immutable about the way the two parties currently line up. Republicans used to be the big-government progressive party, formed in opposition to slavery and pushing to remodel the South after the civil war; they have also been the small-government party, not only now, but in opposition to the New Deal in the 1930s. Democrats were once the small-government party, opposing those who wanted a more powerful federal government and defending the interests of white southerners against Washington; now they are famous as the big-government party, pushing federal anti-poverty programmes in the 20th century and government involvement in health care in the 21st.

Political parties are not religions. They are not nationalities. They are not perfect and they are not permanent. They are simply groups of like-minded people who band together in the hope of having more of a say in how they are governed.

I am not obliged to support any one of them.

In this time of Donald Trump, this time of discontent and proud disloyalty and redrawn lines, who can say what the Republican Party stands for anymore?

I have no confidence that the Party that will be on the ballot in November will in any way reflect my values or my priorities. So no, I won’t pledge to support the Party’s eventual nominee. I’m tired of feeling bound to a group that seems more scattered, more angry, more dysfunctional every year.

I think I’m done now.

These Walls - A Vote of No Confidence in the Republican Party


8 thoughts on “A Vote of No Confidence in the Republican Party

  1. Julie,

    That was me about 15 years ago. I grew up in the Democratic party as my parents (dad mostly) felt that moving to America meant you were democratic. That led to some heated discussions at the dinner table as my own convictions led me to more conservative political activity and a very strong involvement in the Republican party.

    When I moved to Texas, I began to see more clearly how much party affiliation began to trump (pardon the expression) rational thought or discourse. Not to belittle Texans, whatsoever, but being “conservative” in the South was very different than being a Republican on campus in Iowa.

    Moreover, the deeper I fell in love with the faith, with Scripture, with the social teachings of the Church, the more I began to feel the heart of Jesus, I realized that I could never belong to any party. None at this time in history are open to correction, and both in their own ways continue to move further away from the center of our hearts and out into the extreme fringes of radicalism that polarizes and divides us as people.

    This election is just a very vivid demonstration of what the rhetoric and momentum of the loudest on either side have long been pulling toward. Violent opposition. Emotional outbursts replacing civil discourse.

    We are most definitely at a turning point in history. I truly believe “the party” cannot come together to bring us back to the hope and civility that Senator Rubio spoke of so eloquently last night. Since the emergence of the Tea Party movement especially, I have felt strongly that there needs to be a split. Take the middle of both parties and bring them together to see if we can find common ground. Let go of the golden calf of abortion. Shatter the myth of the devilish immigrant.

    There is so much more, but I’ve already made this less of a comment and more of a diatribe. Sorry!! Maybe we mamas should just get our shtuff together and form our own “Don’t Be a Meaniepants” party! 😉

  2. Great post. I think political parties have outlived their usefulness, honestly. I refer to myself as a pro-life Democrat as a shortcut way of defining most of my political beliefs, but I don’t feel any overwhelming party loyalty. At this moment I am more concerned that we have a President who is competent to lead, whether I agree with his or her positions or not.

  3. I too grew up in the Republican party. I’m still registered one, but after this cycle I think I’ll move to independent, even though that means I can’t vote in the primaries here in Maryland. Like Rakhi above, I believe that faith should inform politics, not the other way around. This election threw down the gauntlet for Catholics, I think. I’ve most just been sad, though. It’s very depressing watching your family members who you thought were staunch Catholics now decide that their party comes first.

  4. Like you, I grew up Republican. My family wasn’t involved in politics, but I was saturated in it nonetheless. In high school I started reading my dad’s copies of National Review and The Weekly Standard, and I could argue a blue streak on why the Democratic Party was Satan. Like many folks though, I went to college, encountered other opinions, read many differing points of view. I decided that I wasn’t really Republican during the water boarding fiasco; if being Republican meant pro torture, or using weasel words to say it’s not torture, then I’m not Rep. But…. They at least claimed to be anti abortion, and there was still a visceral dislike of liberals inside of me. Well, Trump did the final cut. So long, farewell.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.